Guides

Armed vs Unarmed Security Guards: Which Do You Need?

How to decide from your site's real risk, plus the licensing, cost and liability differences

By Bannerman · Published

Most businesses need an unarmed security guard. An armed guard makes sense when your site faces a credible threat of serious violence that a firearm would actually change, such as large amounts of cash or valuables on hand, a history of armed robbery, or a remote site far from police. Armed guards usually need extra state licensing, cost more and add liability.

This guide walks through how to tell which you need, what the law requires, what each costs and the questions to settle before you ask for a quote.

What’s the difference between an armed and an unarmed security guard?

An armed security guard carries a firearm on duty and, in most states, holds a firearm permit on top of the regular guard license. An unarmed security guard doesn’t carry a gun. Both do the same core job: being visible, watching, controlling who gets in, writing reports and calling the police. Neither is a police officer.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Occupational Outlook Handbook sums up the gap between the two jobs: “Positions for armed guards have more stringent background checks and entry requirements than do those for unarmed guards,” and “Training is more rigorous for armed guards because they require weapons training.”1

Unarmed security guardArmed security guard
Carries a firearmNoYes
LicenseState guard license or registration, in most statesUsually a guard license plus a separate state firearm permit
Training (New York)8 hours before work, 16 hours on the job, 8 hours every year2All of that, plus a 47-hour firearms course and 8 hours of firearms training every year2
Wage (New York City prevailing wage, July 2026)$18.87 an hour for a guard with less than 36 months’ service3$33.70 an hour3
Typical postsOffices, lobbies, residential buildings, retail, construction sites, most eventsCash handling, high-value goods, sites with a history of armed crime, some government posts
Main tradeoffCan’t stop an armed attacker; watches, deters and calls for help earlyCan respond to an armed threat, but costs more, adds liability and brings a firearm into every incident

When is an unarmed security guard enough?

An unarmed security guard is enough when the risks at your site are trespassing, theft, vandalism, disorder and the need to control who comes in. That covers most offices, apartment buildings, stores, warehouses, construction sites and events. For those risks, what matters is a visible, alert guard who reports problems and calls the police early; a gun adds little.

Even banks, the classic target of armed robbery, mostly rely on other measures. In 2023, the FBI recorded 1,362 robberies, burglaries and larcenies at federally insured financial institutions. Guards were on duty during 153 of them, and the FBI counted armed guards in 39, according to the FBI’s Bank Crime Statistics for 2023. Surveillance cameras were activated in 1,208.4

Unarmed guards are usually the right fit for:

For a site that needs eyes on it overnight but not a guard standing there every hour, mobile patrol is a cheaper option: a patrol officer visits on a schedule and logs what they find.

When do you need an armed security guard?

You need an armed security guard when there’s a credible threat of serious violence that a trained, armed officer could stop. Reasons include large amounts of cash or high-value goods on site or in transit, a history of armed robbery, violence or threats at the location, a remote site far from police, or a law, contract or insurer that requires one.

A useful test is the list of factors federal banking rules tell banks to weigh when choosing security measures. Under 12 CFR 208.61, a bank’s security officer considers “the incidence of crimes against financial institutions in the area,” “the amount of currency and other valuables exposed to robbery, burglary, or larceny,” “the distance of the banking office from the nearest responsible law enforcement officers,” the cost, the other security measures in place and the building’s physical characteristics.5 Any business can use the same questions:

Glade Johnson, then a security company owner and chairman of the Georgia Board of Private Detective and Security Agencies, put the question bluntly to Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting in 2014: “When they ask for them, my first question is always, ‘Who do you want us to shoot?’”6 When the answer is “nobody,” the post usually doesn’t need a gun.

Does any law require an armed security guard?

Usually not. Most private businesses aren’t legally required to have armed guards, or any guards at all. The federal rule for bank security programs lists required devices, such as alarms and locks, but not guards.5 A lease, a venue contract, a government contract or your insurer can still require armed cover.

Two examples:

If someone tells you a guard must be armed, ask for the rule or clause in writing. It may come from your landlord, a venue, your insurer, a government contract or a local permit, and each can set different requirements.

What license does an armed security guard need?

An armed security guard usually needs a state firearm permit on top of the standard guard license, and the requirements are stricter than for unarmed guards. Depending on the state, that means a higher minimum age, firearms training and range qualification, criminal background checks through the FBI, regular requalification and, in some states, a psychological test. Check your state’s regulator.

Four state examples:

Ask the security company for the firearm permit or commission number of each armed guard on your post, not only the guard license, and look it up with your state’s regulator. In California, both licenses show up on the state’s license search. For more on checking a company, see 8 questions to ask before hiring a security guard company.

How much more does an armed security guard cost?

An armed security guard costs more than an unarmed one, and the gap depends on location. In New York City’s prevailing wage, an armed guard must be paid at least $33.70 an hour against $18.87 for a newer unarmed guard (July 2026).3 On Illinois state contracts outside the Chicago area, the gap is $25.90 against $23.38 (September 2026).11

Those are wage floors set for covered contracts, not what a business is billed. The bill rate also covers payroll taxes, insurance, supervision and the company’s margin, and armed work adds firearms training, requalification and higher liability insurance on top. The two sources:

For federal rate ceilings, a monthly budget and how to read a quote, see how much a security guard costs.

What are the risks of putting an armed guard on your site?

An armed guard brings a firearm into every incident on your property, and that has costs beyond the hourly rate. Confrontations can escalate, mistakes can be deadly, and if a guard uses force, your business may be drawn into what follows. Your insurer, your landlord and your staff may all have a view, so ask before you decide.

One large look at the data is a 2014 analysis by Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting of more than 31,000 bank robberies, burglaries and larcenies the FBI recorded from 2007 to 2011. It found that an armed guard’s presence made a violent outcome three times more likely, and that armed guards were injured at a rate of 64 per 1,000 incidents, against fewer than 1 per 1,000 for unarmed guards.6 The data is more than a decade old and comes from banks, so it doesn’t prove that a gun causes violence at your site. It does show that an armed guard doesn’t automatically make an incident calmer.

Before you put an armed guard on a post, find out:

Can you use both armed and unarmed guards?

Yes. Many sites use unarmed guards for most posts and add armed cover only where and when the risk is highest. A store might keep an unarmed guard at the door all day and add an armed guard for opening, closing or cash pickups.

A large site might post an armed guard at a cash room or loading dock while unarmed guards handle the lobby and patrols. Mixing the two keeps the cost and liability of armed cover limited to the hours and places that justify it. It also means you can start unarmed and add armed cover later if incidents show you need it. Write the difference into the post orders, so every guard knows what their post covers and who to call.

Armed or unarmed: how to decide before you ask for a quote

Decide on armed or unarmed from the risks you can name at your site, not from the assumption that armed is always safer. If you can’t point to a credible threat of violence a firearm would change, start with an unarmed guard. If you can, ask for armed cover only at the posts and hours that need it.

Before you contact security companies, write down:

  1. The incidents you’re trying to prevent, with dates if you have them.
  2. What’s at stake: cash, inventory, people, access to the building.
  3. Any rule or contract that requires armed cover, in writing.
  4. The posts and hours where each kind of guard is needed.
  5. Your insurer’s answer on armed security.

Whether you contact companies directly or request a quote through Bannerman, say armed or unarmed and why, so every company prices the same job. The security company that covers your area confirms what it can staff, and the price, after reviewing the job. If you already have armed guards and something has gone wrong, read 7 signs it’s time to fire your security guard company.

Sources

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Security Guards and Gambling Surveillance Officers”, Occupational Outlook Handbook, https://www.bls.gov/ooh/protective-service/security-guards.htm, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  2. New York Department of State, “Security Guard Training Requirements”, https://dos.ny.gov/security-guard-training-requirements, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  3. New York State Department of Labor, “Guards, Security” (prevailing wage schedule for the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and Staten Island), https://apps.labor.ny.gov/wpp/previewPublicWageSchedule.do?id=5424&scheduleType=123, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  4. Federal Bureau of Investigation, “Bank Crime Statistics (BCS), Federally Insured Financial Institutions, January 1, 2023 - December 31, 2023”, https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/bank-crime-statistics-2023-091724.pdf, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  5. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, “12 CFR 208.61 Bank security procedures”, https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-12/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-208/subpart-F/section-208.61, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  6. Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting, “FBI bank robbery data shows armed guards increase risk of violence” (2014), https://revealnews.org/article/fbi-bank-robbery-data-shows-armed-guards-increase-risk-of-violence/, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩ ↩2

  7. Legal Information Institute, “Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 4, § 15045 - Security Personnel”, https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/4-CCR-15045, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  8. California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, “Firearms Permit Fact Sheet”, https://www.bsis.ca.gov/forms_pubs/fire_fact.pdf, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  9. Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, “Class G Statewide Firearm License Requirements”, https://www.fdacs.gov/Business-Services/Private-Investigation-Licenses/Class-G-Statewide-Firearm-License-Requirements, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  10. Texas Legislature, “Occupations Code, Chapter 1702. Private Security” (sections 1702.161, 1702.163 and 1702.1675), https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/OC/htm/OC.1702.htm, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩

  11. Illinois Department of Labor, “Illinois Prevailing Wage Rates Pursuant to the Illinois Finance Procurement Code: Security Guards, Effective September 1, 2026”, https://labor.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/idol/laws-rules/conmed/rates/2026-security-rates/2026%20Security%20rates%20downstate%20Illinois.pdf, accessed 2026-11-17 ↩ ↩2

Written and reviewed by the Bannerman team.

Get matched

Need help putting this into practice?

Tell us about your space and we'll pass your request to a local security company in your area.

Get a quote